Research shows shoppers trust AI more than influencers. Hannah McIntosh at Croud explains how to ensure LLMs say the right things about your brand.
Consumers increasingly treat AI as a trusted and highly personalized shopping companion, explains McIntosh (Money Knack via Unsplash)
The era of the celebrity endorsement is quietly giving way to something more algorithm-driven. According to our recent report, Croud Consumer Index: AI, LLMs and the Next Frontier of Search, 68% of ‘AI adopters’ say they trust AI recommendations more than celebrity or influencer endorsements.
The report explores how large language models (LLMs) are reshaping the way people discover and decide what to buy. Consumers are increasingly turning to LLMs, such as ChatGPT and Gemini, for product research, with one in six AI users now completing their entire discovery journey within such tools.
At the rate things are moving, LLMs aren’t just assisting in the buying journey. These platforms are becoming tomorrow’s personal shoppers.
AI is quickly transforming how consumers uncover brands, acting as a trusted and highly personalized shopping companion. While a significant minority (17%) complete their entire discovery journey within AI tools, even more consumers (34%) are turning to AI right at the start of their product research.
Advertisement
I’ve felt the shift first-hand when doing my own product research, especially in the category that happily drains my disposable income: fragrance. I came across a new hidden gem of a perfume recently during a quick SpaceNK browse, but it was AI that helped me make the purchase. A quick voice search surfaced the things that matter to me: its vegan and cruelty-free credentials, the family-owned origin story, and honest reviews on scent staying power. The whole discovery experience felt far more tailored than getting into a round of questions with a store rep.
It’s undeniable that this early AI influence is driving measurable change in purchasing behavior. Forty-one percent of consumers say their favorite brand of the year was actually first discovered through AI, and 68% have been inspired to buy brands they’d never previously considered, which further underlines the influence. With 61% expecting to search for most products using AI within the next five years, LLMs are emerging as the new entry point for brand discovery.
So, what is driving this new wave of trust? This shift is underpinned by consumers’ belief in AI’s neutrality and data-driven objectivity. People view AI as an unbiased authority that cuts through the brand marketing noise to surface genuinely relevant options.
This makes sense when we look at the platforms that LLMs increasingly cite, such as Reddit. As Vogue Business has highlighted, male shoppers are increasingly using Reddit threads as their primary research hub, trusting candid reviews and real side-by-side comparisons. LLMs are only accelerating this shift, surfacing Reddit discussions as credible sources when people ask for ‘the best,’ ‘what brands are trending?’ or the occasionally more abstract style query, such as whether that baseball cap belongs anywhere near that smart coat.
This all puts a fresh spotlight on the value of digital PR. As Robby Stein, VP of Product for Google Search, discussed recently, high-quality PR activity that earns authoritative coverage and genuine relevance plays a meaningful role in how brands surface in AI-driven results. In a landscape where LLMs prioritize authority signals, digital PR isn’t just reputation-building; it’s now becoming a fundamental part of how brands stay visible in the age of AI-powered search. Digital PR should no longer be viewed as the ‘nice-to-have’ channel in the organic mix – it is becoming the main character.
With consumer behaviors shifting rapidly, the advantage lies with those brands willing to be ‘first-movers’ to get ahead. Here are four key considerations:
The brands that will win in this new landscape are those that combine data-driven discoverability with authentic, verifiable trust, ensuring they show up credibly in the spaces where AI acts as the ultimate personal shopper.
Croud
We're an independent global media, creative, and data agency helping our clients make their next best move. We help brands unlock growth with a Return on Intelligence...